Interesting! I refer you to a post I made on a different thread. There certainly appear to be two (very different) sides to this story. I love the way that a couple of things have been posted on here recently and the 'combatants' have come on line to discuss their varying views of events. If nothing else, these discussions certainly go to show how difficult the umpires' job is, when two people participating in the same event, seeing the same incidents, interpret them so differently*. It just goes to show that a belief in the certainty of "one truth" about an event is dangerous - perhaps something that we umpires should remember when we're certain we've seen something but everyone else appears to disagree... * Max, I appreciate that Controller wasn't at the game in question, but clearly someone has relayed a version of events to him that is somewhat at odds with yours!